History 480: Major Seminar in American History I

Fall, 2007
Wednesdays, 5:30 - 8:00 p.m.
LOCATION: SIS 14

           THE  SYLLABUS
 

Instructor:  Robert Griffith

Office: 137-9  Battelle-Tompkins

Office Hours:  M -W, 2:00 -5:00 p.m. & by appt.

Tel: 202-885-2419

 E-Mail: bgriff@american.edu

 Robert Griffith's Home Page


 
To navigate the syllabus, click on the following links:

About the Course

The Schedule

Readings and Library Resources

Assignments

Blackboard

The Groups

Assessment & Academic Integrity

Word/Endnote/PowerPoint

Notice: although this web based syllabus is reasonably complete, I  will make alterations in it from time to time as circumstances change or as new opportunities for learning present themselves. I  will usually indicate such changes with the image: .   If you discover broken links or other errors, please contact Professor Griffith at: bgriff@american.edu.



About the Course: This is the first of a two semester sequence on history and historical research. Its goal is to help you conceive, plan, research, write and present an original work of scholarship on a topic of your choice.  To better understand the context for this course, see the History Department's goals for history majors.

  • During the first semester you will familiarize yourselves with the breadth and depth of  historical studies, adding to what you have already learned about the variety of historical practice. 
  • You will strengthen your research skills --defining a topic for your paper, conducting a literature search among secondary readings on the topic, and identifying relevant and accessible primary documents.   
  • You will sharpen your communication skills through frequent written assignments and oral reports. 
  • By the end of the semester you will be asked to submit a prospectus or research proposal, describing your topic, the relevant secondary and primary sources, and the schedule by which (during the spring semester) you will complete the paper. 
  • You will also make a brief, Power Point presentation on your topic.
  • During the second semester you will complete the research and writing of your paper and make Power Point presentations based upon your paper at the Department's annual "history day,"  the College of Arts and Humanities' Undergraduate Research Conference and/or at the annual Regional Conference of  Phi Alpha Theta, the history honorary.

Two Alternative Formats: Your project may be presented in either of two formats:

  • The usual format is a that of a scholarly article of approximately 35-40 pages( 9,000-10,000 words), not including footnotes.  You will also be expected to make a brief, 10-15 minute Power Point presentation based on your paper.
     
  • Alternatively, you are welcome to present your research as a web site, incorporating not only traditional methods of presenting research, but also (where appropriate) scanned and/or webbed documents, images, sounds, links, etc.  Technical help will be available for those who elect this alternative.  (If you select this alternative, you are very strongly advised to sign up in the spring semester for History 377: History in the Digital Age.   Please note, however, that such presentations must meet the same very rigorous standards applied to traditional papers.  Indeed, in some ways the expectations for these presentations may be even higher.  Moreover, any web based presentation must be accompanied by a brief reflection on how working in this newer medium may have affected both your research and presentation.  For details on and examples about how new information technologies are transforming the practice of history, click on the web site of my spring, 2002, course: History in the Digital Age.


The Importance of Community:

  • Because scholarship is a collegial as well as an individual enterprise, you will be asked to share your work with others at every stage: seeking (and offering) advice and revising your work in light of the comments by your classmates and the instructor.  Your grade for the course will be based not only on the quality of your own work, but on the quality and helpfulness of assistance that you lend to your classmates.  For this purpose, I have divided the class into five groups, somewhat facetiously and crudely named after "schools" of historical interpretation.  Each group has its own group pages, which may be reached by clicking on "Communication" and then on "Group Pages."  NOTE: everyone is a member of every group, so it is possible for anyone to drop in and read and/or comment on the work of any group. 

Here are the initial group assignments.  TBA

 
 
 
 
 

Blackboard: 

  • Much of the work of the class will be conducted through Blackboard, the University's preferred "course management" software.  Blackboard provides a virtual classroom environment where you may find a link to this syllabus and other course materials, including readings available via the Library's Electronic Reserve. Blackboard also provides "discussion forums" in which you will be required to post your weekly assignments and comment on the work of your classmates.  To access the newest version of Blackboard, click on https://blackboard.american.edu.   Login, your Eaglenet ID and Password.  Click on History 480(I). 

The Assignments: 

  • Much of  early work of the course is organized around a series of written assignments.  These assignments are designed  to help you hone your research skills, to read carefully, to think critically about what you have read, to organize your own thoughts and to communicate those thoughts effectively.  Think of the individual assignments as building blocks.  They are organized so that the final product of the course, a well designed and well written research proposal (leading, next spring, to a well researched and well written seminar paper), should evolve naturally over the course of the semester. 
     
  • For many of these assignments you will be asked to
        a) "post" an essay to be read by either the entire class or by the other members of your group; and to
        b)  post a comment on each of the essays prepared by the other members of your group. 
     
  • It is absolutely critical that you post your essay by the scheduled deadline, which in most cases will be on Sunday evening, three  days before our scheduled class.  This is to provide time for your team mates to read and submit comments on what you have posted before the class meets. Assignments posted after the deadline will not receive full credit
     

Assessment:

  • Your grade will be based on the quality of your work throughout the course.   And because the seminar format assumes that you will be contributing to the learning of your classmates, you will also be graded on the quality and helpfulness of your comments on the work of others.  For similar reasons, your participation, measured both by your presence in class and on the Blackboard web site, will also figure into your final grade.  It goes without saying that your work in the course must be yours and yours alone. If you draw ideas and important information from a source, you must identify that source.  If you use language that is not your own, it must be placed in quotes and its source identified. Failure to do so, plagiarism, is one of the most serious violations of the Academic Integrity Code. For details, see Assessment.

Need Help?

  • If you experience difficulty in this course for any reason, please don’t hesitate to consult with me. In addition to the resources of the department, a wide range of services is available to support you in your efforts to meet the course requirements.

     

    Academic Support Center (x3360, MGC 243) offers study skills workshops, individual instruction, tutor referrals, and services for students with learning disabilities. Writing support is available in the ASC Writing Lab or in the Writing Center, Battelle 228.

    Counseling Center (x3500, MGC 214) offers counseling and consultations regarding personal concerns, self-help information, and connections to off-campus mental health resources.

    Disability Support Services (x3315, MGC 206) offers technical and practical support and assistance with accommodations for students with physical, medical, or psychological disabilities.

     
    If you qualify for accommodations because of a disability
    , please notify me in a timely manner with a letter from the Academic Support Center or Disability Support Services so that we can make arrangements to address your needs.

    For details, click on: http://www.american.edu/ocl/dss/index1.html.

Word, Endnote, Zotero & Power Point: 

  • All assignments, including your prospectus, should be prepared in Word or some other Word-compatible software. You will be expected to make a brief,  Power Point presentation of your prospectus at the end of the first semester, and a more extensive and detailed presentation at "History Day" at the end of the second semester.  Power Point is easy to learn.  The University's Center for Teaching Excellence offers Power Point training sessions throughout the semester. For details, see the CTE Training Calendar. You can also get assistance at the University's various computing labs.  Students in Major Seminar are very strongly encouraged to purchase Endnote, a very powerful bibliographical and note-taking tool that can save you literally hundreds of hours.  It costs less than $100.00 with your student discount, and is worth every cent of it.  A member of the Library's reference staff will give a tutorial on how to use Endnote early in the semester.  A recently developed (and free!) alternative to Endnote is Zotero, a software program developed by George Mason University's Center for History and New Media.



Required:

Jules R. Benjamin, A Student's Guide to History (ninth edition, 2004).  For an abridged, online version of the 8th edition, click on: http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/history/benjamin/

Patrick Rael,  Reading, Writing, and Researching for History: A Guide for College Students (2004), online at: http://academic.bowdoin.edu/WritingGuides/

Please download a free, 30 trial version of  Endnote (if you decide to purchase it, you will need to pay around $100.00).  And/or download  Zotero, a free open source program.

Kate L. Turabian, John Grossman, and Alice Bennett, A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and Dissertations, 6th revised edition (Chicago:  University of Chicago Press, 1996). Long the "bible" for history graduate students, much of the material in this volume is available online.  See, for example, the Library's citation style guide page at: http://www.library.american.edu/subject/citation.html#tur.  A useful citation guide for web based sources is History professor Melvin Page's Brief Citation Guide for Internet Sources in History and the Humanities, accessible at: http://www2.h-net.msu.edu/about/citation/.

H-Net, Humanities Social Sciences On Line: --this very important site serves as a central information storehouse for H-Net's extensive network of e-mail lists. You should subscribe to one or more of these lists, depending on your own particular interests.

Recommended Readings:


Martha Howell and Walter Prevenier, From Reliable Sources (Cornell University, 2001).

Andrea A. Lunsford, A Pocket Guide to Easy Writer (2nd edition, Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2002).

Thomas Mann, The Oxford Guide to Library Research, 2nd edition, (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998).

Francis Paul Prucha, Handbook for Research in American History (2nd edition, revised, 1994).  (Has especially useful chapters on primary sources.)

Mary Lynn Rampolla, A Pocket Guide to Writing in History, 3rd ed. (Boston: Bedford Books/St. Martin's Press, 2001). Includes a guide to Chicago-style citations.

William Strunk, Jr. and E. B. White, The Elements of Style, 3rd edition (New York: Macmillan, 1995).  Originally written by William Strunk (and available on-line by clicking on The Elements of  Style), this slender volume was updated by E.B. White in the late 1950s.  A little fussy for contemporary sensibilities, it is still a valuable guide to good writing.  See also, Tips on Good Writing.

Dennis A. Trinkle and Scott A. Merriman, The History Highway 3.0 (revised edition, 2002). An extensive list of history related web sites.  The new edition comes with a very useful CD with links to many bibliographies and other research materials.

The History News Service.  A gossipy grapevine about current issues of interest to historians.  Please subscribe to the network and receive it's regular e-mails.  From time to time in class we'll discuss what's hot (and not)!

And a variety of articles and essays and web sites, available through the Library's various databases, through Blackboard's Electronic Reserve, or plucked from the world wide webTo access the Library's databases, click on Aladin or (if you have configured your own personal library page - highly recommended), on myAladin.

The American University Library and Other Resources:

American University Library -- click on here to access the AU Library Main page, with links to Aladin (the WRLC catalogue) and a variety of electronic databases.  Click here to access a series of tutorials designed to help you use the AU library in researching your thesis: http://www.library.american.edu/Help/index.html

Especially useful are Academic Search Premier (EBESCO), Proquest, JSTOR,  and Project Muse (which includes recent years of many other journals,  including American Quarterly and Reviews in American History).   See also, the large collection of databases at OCLC (which includes recent issues of the journal, Diplomatic History), and at Lexis-NexisAmerican History and Life is a very useful source for scholarly bibliographical citations. Archives USA, is a valuable guide to archival collections that can save scholars much time (and money!) in searching for primary documents.  See also the Library's guide to Resources by Subject, including especially History, American Studies, and Women and Gender Studies.


THE SCHEDULE

August 29

September 5

September 12

September 19

September 26

October 3

October 10

October 17

October 24

October 31

November 7

November 14

November 28

December 5

December 14: Final Draft Due

 

 


 History is a way of learning.  As such, it begins by leaving the present; by going back into the heretofore, by beginning again.  Only by grasping what we were is it possible to see how we changed, to understand the process and the nature of the modifications, and to gain some perspective on what we are.  The historical experience is not one of staying in the present and looking back.  Rather is it one of going back into the past and returning to the present with a wide and more intense consciousness of the restrictions of our former outlook.  We return with a broader awareness of the alternatives open to us and armed with a sharper perceptiveness with which to make our choices.  In this manner it is possible to loosen the clutch of the past and transform it into a living tool for the present and the future. --  William A. Williams.

*For these & other quotations, see  Thoughts On History.

  

Wednesday, August 29:  Introductions. 


Assignment One: Questionnaire, Autobiography and Homepage.  Due Before First Class:

The Questionnaire:  You should have received by now an e-mail attachment with a questionnaire.  Please fill out this questionnaire and return it to me by e-mail in advance of our first class.  If you have not received a copy, please download the questionnaire (click here), fill it out and return it to me as soon as possible.

Your Blackboard Homepage: Create a class "homepage" for yourself  by going to Blackboard, entering your Eaglenet ID and Pass Word, and clicking on "Student Tools" and then on "edit your homepage."   If you wish, by all means attach a photo or links to your own webpage (if you have one), to  myplace, facebook or your favorite sites.

The Autobiography:  Also in advance of Wednesday's class, we would like for each of you to prepare a brief (500-750 word) "intellectual biography" in which you tell us a little about yourself and your background: where you grew up, your education prior to enrolling at AU, the classes (not just history classes) and ideas that have really excited you during your college years, and your goals, both immediate and long term.  In particular, indicate possible topics you might wish to research and write about over the course of the next two semesters.  Post your essay on the Blackboard Discussion Board, by clicking on "Communication, " then on "Blackboard Discussion Boards" and finally, on "Autobiography."  Add you own essay by clicking on "Add a New Thread. "   You may paste your essay into Blackboard's dialogue box from Word or whatever word processing software you use; or you may attach it using Blackboard's file attachment feature.

 Review what your fellow students have written. 

Come to class prepared to talk about yourself and ask questions about others.

In class:  Introductions to one another and to the work of the class.  Prepare to introduce yourself and say a few words about your particular interests, both historical and otherwise. 


Wednesday, September 5: Exploring the Many Varieties of History

The past is a foreign country. They do things differently there. Anon.

Assignment Two: The purpose of this assignment is to familiarize yourself with the many varieties of history study and the communities of scholars in each.   For those who already have a firm idea of what you want to do, it's a chance to begin to discover what others have written about the topic and where you can find "conversations" about your topic.  For those of you still undecided, this is an opportunity to explore the huge menu of possibilities. Begin with a topic that you are (or might be) interested in investigating for your Major Seminar Paper.  See especially,  Defining Your Topic.  Then, familiarize yourself with The Many Varieties of American History.  Once you have done that, then:

(a)   Locate one or more historical organizations related to your topic. Familiarize yourself with the organization. If at all possible, locate the program (either in print or on the web) for its annual  meeting (either a recent or soon to be held conference).  Browse the titles of some of the papers given (or to be given) at the conference.  Cite specific examples.  What do they tell you about the range of topics explored by the organization? Give some examples.  Note: a partial list of such organization is maintained by the American Historical Association and can be reviewed at: http://www.historians.org/affiliates/index.cfm. See also a list of historical organizations posted by the Organization of American Historians at: http://www.oah.org/announce/links.html.

(b)   Locate two or more scholarly journals that publish materials in the area in which you are interested.  To do this, go to the Library portal (Aladin/Databases/History/JSTOR).  JSTOR is a major repository for scholarly articles. Click on "Browse" and then on "History" for list of journals included in JSTOR.  Do the same things for Project Muse, clicking on "journals" for a list. 

Note that many journals listed on JSTOR  do not include the last five years, while Project Muse includes only recent volumes.  Note also (this is important!) that JSTOR contains only a relatively small number of all scholarly articles.  Access to some of these may be found through the two large databases (Academic Search Premier -EBSCO and Proquest Research Library).  But many, many others are available only in hard copy; for these you must use Bender Library, the Library of  Congress  and/or Interlibrary Loan.  The Library's Reference Librarians can be especially helpful in locating such journals.

An example of  how this (a and b) might be done:  For example, exploring a topic on the Cuban Missile Crisis might lead you to the Society for the History of American Foreign Relations (SHAFR),  to this years annual meeting and to its journal, Diplomatic History.  A little more investigation might lead you to the Harvard Project on Cold War Studies and its journal, The Journal of Cold War Studies.

(c)  Locate at least one H-Net Discussion Group (H-Net, Humanities and Social Sciences Online) that might be relevant to your topic.  Click on "discussion networks."  (For the Cuban Missile Crisis, for example, it might be H-Diplo.)  Explore the group's discussion logs, as well as any other resources identified on its web site.  Describe and discuss some of the issues debated by the discussion group.  Explore the group's web site.  If you think you will be researching in this field, become a subscriber.  Note: there are many discussion groups,  some of which are extremely active and others that are only intermittently active.

(d)  Prepare a brief (750 word essay) describing what you have learned.  Discuss the organization (s), journal (s) and H-Net group (s) you have identified and how they may (or may not) relate to your own topic.  Post your essay on your (Blackboard) Class discussion board no later than Monday evening. 

(e): Post substantive comments on the work of the other members of your group before class on Wednesday. 

In Class:  

Come to class prepared to briefly report on what you have discovered. Organize your presentation carefully. It should run no more than five to seven minutes, with a few minutes for Q & A from the class.  For details, see especially Tips for Making a Class Presentation.

 



Wednesday, September 12: Some Tools of the Trade:

Historians are left forever chasing shadows, painfully aware of their inability ever to reconstruct a dead world in its completeness however thorough or revealing their documentation. We are doomed to be forever hailing someone who has just gone around the corner and out of earshot. -- Simon Schama

NOTE:  CLASS MEETS IN BENDER LIBRARY E-CLASSROOM (in the basement).

Assignment Three:  In researching and writing your senior thesis, you will invariably take many notes (and wish you had taken many more).  Taking good notes and organizing them effectively can save you enormous amounts of time and effort.  Fortunately, there is technology at hand to make this far more simple than in the past.  The two best examples of this are Endnote and Zotero.  Endnote is a powerful bibliographic tool, with some note taking capabilities.  One of its strongest features is its ability to download bibliographic citations from almost any library in the world, file them as notes, format them in any style, and plug them into footnotes and bibliographies in your thesis.  And it does this without the laborious and error-ridden work of typing them in by hand.  You can download a free, 30 day trail version of Endnote at: http://www.endnote.com/.    It costs around 100.00 with your student discount, and is worth every cent of it.  More recently, the smart folks at George Mason University's Center for History and New Media have developed an open source (e.g., free) software that is in some (not all) ways superior to Endnote.  The purpose of this assignment is to familiarize you with either or both of these powerful tools and how they can assist you in researching and writing your senior thesis.

a)  Read: Jules R. Benjamin, "How to Research a History Topic," A Student's Guide to History (ninth edition, 2004), at: http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/history/benjamin/con_index.htm?res.  See especially the sections on note taking; also read the section on "Research Papers" in Patrick Rael,  Reading, Writing, and Researching for History: A Guide for College Students (2004), online at: http://academic.bowdoin.edu/WritingGuides/

b) Download a free 30 day trail version of Endnote and/ or a free version of  Zotero.  Spend some time familiarizing yourself  with your programs' capabilities.  How might you use it to take notes, download citations from libraries or from the web.  By Monday post a brief  assessment of the program on the Blackboard's Class Discussion Board.   Indicate your own level of comfort with the program, as well as difficulties you may have encountered and questions you may wish to raise in class.  Before class on Wednesday, browse the postings by other members of the class.  Where you can make a useful comment or answer a question someone has raised, do so.

In Class: Workshop on Endnote led by Senior Reference Librarian Mary Mintz.  Come to class prepared to discuss what you have learned and questions you may have about Endnote.  (We will explore Zotero the following week, September 19.)

 


 

Wednesday, September 19:  History and the Library's Electronic Frontier

Reality happens to be, like a landscape, possessed of an infinite number of perspectives, all equally veracious and authentic. The sole false perspective is that which claims to be the only one there is.  -- José Ortega y  Gasset

Assignment Four:  The purpose of this assignment is to increase your familiarity with the strengths (and limitations) of the Library's large number of electronic database.  These databases have not only vastly expanded the holdings of our Library (making it the equal of many larger libraries with more hard copy books and articles), but also transforming the research experience through their powerful (if you know what you are doing) search engines. 

a)  In advance of our class meeting, familiarize yourself with the many electronic  databases now available to students, staff and faculty through the Library's ALADIN web site. 

Especially useful for scholarly articles are (to name a few) Academic Search Premier (EBSCO), Proquest,  JSTOR  and Project Muse (which includes recent years of many other journals,  including American Quarterly and Reviews in American History).     American History and Life is a very useful source for scholarly bibliographical citations with links to many of those that are available online via other library databases.

Archives USA, is a valuable guide to archival collections that can save scholars much time (and money!) in searching for primary documents.  The Government Documents database is wonderful for politics and government.  It also includes a link to the National Security Archive, a terrific source for documents released following freedom and information suits.  Lexis-Nexis is mostly useful for searching recent newspapers.  Historical (and searchable!) runs of newspapers available through our library include the Washington Post, the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, the Chicago Tribune and the Atlanta JournalSee also the Library's guide to Resources by Subject, including especially History, American Studies, and Women and Gender Studies. If you have questions about locating these databases, visit the Reference desk, call x3243, or write to research@american.edu.  

 b) By Monday, post to your Class discussion board a brief 500 word essay describing in some detail two of these databases.  One of them should give you access to important secondary works in history; the other should provide you with access to important primary materials.  Your essay should address what is (and is not) included in each of these databases?  How do you go about searching them?  How might they be used in preparing your (or someone else's) study.   What are their limitations? 

MAKE EVERY EFFORT NOT TO DUPLICATE WHAT SOMEONE ELSE IN THE SEMINAR IS DOING  AS A GENERAL RULE,  NO MORE THAN TWO STUDENTS SHOULD EXPLORE A SINGLE  DATABASE.  ACADEMIC SEARCH PREMIER (EBSCO) AND PROQUEST ARE EXCEPTIONS.  BOTH ARE LARGE META-DATABASES, SO THEY CAN ACCOMMODATE ONE OR TWO ADDITIONAL STUDENTS.  HOWEVER,   IF YOU SELECT ONE OF THESE, PLEASE DRILL DOWN TO EXAMINE A SPECIFIC SET OF JOURNALS (e.g., history, government, etc.).

TO MINIMIZE DUPLICATION, I ASK THAT AT YOUR EARLIEST CONVENIENCE YOU POST THE TWO DATABASES YOU INTEND TO REPORT ON TO THE CLASS DATABASE (NAME YOUR DATABASES).  

Read the essays by the members of the class and post comments on them before class on Wednesday.

Be prepared to discuss the databases that you have selected to examine.

In Class:   From 5:30 to 6:30, Trevor Owens, of the George Mason University Center for History and New Media will make a presentation on Zotero.  The second half of the class will focus on what you have learned about the library's various databases. 



Wednesday, September 26:  History on the [Wild!] World Wide Web

The lessons of history? There are four: The bee fertilizes the flower it robs; whom the gods would destroy they first make mad with power; the mills of God grind slowly, but they grind exceeding small; when it is dark enough, you can see the stars. -- Charles A. Beard

Assignment Five: The purpose of this assignment is to familiarize yourself with historical sources, both primary and secondary, that are available on the world wide web and to sharpen your skills in locating and evaluating such sources.

a)  Read Kelly Schrum, "Surfing for the Past: How to Separate the Good from the Bad," in AHA Perspectives (May 2003), at: http://chnm.gmu.edu/resources/essays/d/7

b)  Second, familiarize yourself with some of the major web search engines.  Explore the Library's Guide to with special attention to the section on "Tips for Searching the Web."  Explore how you can use "Boolean operators" to refine your search processes.  For a usual resource on using different search engines, see the Search Tools page at: http://www.infopeople.org/search/chart.html

c)  Explore some of the  AU Library's disciplinary "gateways" to information on the web. (e.g., see Online Resources).  Focus especially on those sites listed under history, American studies, women and gender studies and the various social sciences.  Also browse the Library's "e-Reference" collection.

d)  Read carefully the criteria in the following two web sites:  Thinking Critically about World Wide Web Resources and  especially Thinking Critically about Discipline-Based World Wide Web.

e)   Sample the web sites collection on the George Mason University "History Matters" website at: http://historymatters.gmu.edu/browse/wwwhistory/.  Select a single web site relating to an historical topic that interests you. Explore it carefully.   

f)  Finally, prepare an essay (c. 500 words)  describing and evaluating the web site you have selected.  Use the criteria from the two UCLA web sites above.  In addition, answer the following questions: Would you characterize the purpose of your site as a) instructional; b) scholarly;  c) archival; or d) some combination?  To what audience is it directed? What are its strengths?  Its limitations?

Post your essay to the class discussion board by Monday evening.   Read and comment on the essays posted by other members of the class by Tuesday p.m.  Come to class prepared to talk about what you have discovered. 


Wednesday, October 3: No Class.  Work on Literature Search and Bibliographical Essay (Due Monday, October 8).

 

A people without history is like wind upon the buffalo grass. - old Teton Sioux saying.

I will be available for individual meetings during office hours and by appointment.

 


Wednesday, October 10:  Discussion of Literature Search and Bibliographical Essay

 As often happens in the search after truth, if we have answered one question, we have raised many more; if we have followed one track home, we have had to pass by others that opened off it and led, or seemed to lead, to far other goals. -- Sir James George Frazer

Assignment Six:  The purpose of this assignment is to prepare a first draft of one of the most important elements in your prospectus (and final paper).  It's called the "literature search."  Your goal is to learn and communicate to the reader a general overview of  the scholarly, secondary literature on your topic - mainly books and scholarly articles.  It is not necessary that you read every one of these books and articles, only that you have a general understanding of what they are about.  The goal, however, is to thoroughly familiarize yourself with existing scholarship on your topic.

(a)  To better understand what a literature search is study the brief guide prepared by the University of Wisconsin at: http://www.wisc.edu/writing/Handbook/ReviewofLiterature.html. Also useful is our own Library's web site at: http://www.library.american.edu/Help/research/lit_review/index.html.

(b)  Conduct an extensive "literature search" on your topic, using the library catalogue, databases and other sources you have explored in earlier weeks.  Compile a "bibliography" of important books and articles relating to your topic.  Use Endnote or Zotero to organize your bibliography.

If possible, locate a recent "essay review" or bibliographical essay on your topic.  Essay reviews typically  discuss recent studies and major issues on a topic.  Good bibliographical essays can sometimes be found in the back of recent books on a topic.  [Using the WRLC catalogue, open the listing for recent books, check under "Notes" to discover whether or not the book has a bibliographical essay.]

Evaluate the books and articles to learn which are the most relevant to your own topic.  In evaluating the quality of the books and articles you discover, see my guide to  Searching for the Best Books and Articles on my Topic  

(c)  Then read and prepare an "essay on secondary sources" describing the books and articles that may relate to your topic. 

Your essay should be approximately 10-12 pages (2500-3000 words).   For details on the required format, click on Review of Secondary Literature.  

Post your essay on the class discussion board   no later than Monday.  Read and post substantive comments on the work of at least three other members of your group before class on Wednesday. 

Come to class prepared to make a brief (5-6 minute), carefully organized oral presentation on what you have discovered.  For details,  see Tips for Making a Class Presentation.

In Class:  Presentation and Discussion of Essay Reviews


Wednesday, October 17: No Class.  Work on Primary Sources Assignment due October 24

History is an argument without end.  Pieter Geyl

I will be available for individual meetings during office hours and by appointment.

 


Wednesday, October 24: Primary Sources.

History, real solemn history, I cannot be interested in. . . . I read it a little as a duty; but it tells me nothing that does not either vex or weary me. The quarrels of popes and kings, with wars and pestilences in every page; the men all so good for nothing, and hardly any women at all. -- Jane Austen

Readings and Resources:

Historical studies are based on a wide range of original sources.  These include, among others,  contemporary newspapers and magazines, government documents, private correspondence, diaries, photographs, maps, census data, material objects (including buildings and monuments), etc., etc., etc.  Read the excellent discussion of primary documents on the Yale University library site at: http://www.library.yale.edu/ref/err/primsrcs.htm.  See also, "How to Read a Primary Source," by Patrick Rael,  Reading, Writing, and Researching for History: A Guide for College Students (2004), online at: http://academic.bowdoin.edu/WritingGuides/; and Making Sense of Evidence, at: http://historymatters.gmu.edu/browse/makesense/Guides to these sources are discussed in Benjamin, A Student's Guide to History, Appendix A, and in other recommended texts.  However, your best guide to these many sources will be the history department faculty and the University's reference librarians.

You can often locate important primary sources by examining the footnotes of the books and articles you have located.

Only a relatively limited number of primary sources are available online.  For collections available through AU Library databases, see the Library website.  For a quick survey of additional materials available on line, visit the George Mason University Center for History and New Media's Guide to History on the Web.

For government documents, use the Library's Government Resources portal. Search the National Archives at: NARA | US National Archives & Records Administration and the Library of Congress at: http://lcweb.loc.gov/.  The Library of Congress maintains an online version of the National Union Guide to Manuscript Collections (NUCMC) at: http://www.loc.gov/coll/nucmc/nucmc.html.  The Library also subscribes to  Archives, USA, a comprehensive and searchable guide to manuscript collections throughout the country.  For an introduction to the extensive research opportunities at the museums and galleries that comprise the Smithsonian Institution, click on: http://www.si.edu/research/.

Assignment Seven: 

1.  Review carefully the guides and resources listed above.

2.  Visit, in person, an area library or archive.  A partial list of area archives may be found on the Department of History's Research Links at: http://www.american.edu/academic.depts/cas/hist/links.html.  Read and talk to staff to learn more about the kinds of materials that are available in the library or archive you visit.  Learn about finding aides and other guides to archival holdings.  If possible (and if required), register to use the archive.  This usually requires filling out a short form.

3.  Make a list of the various kinds of  primary sources that might be relevant to your topic.  Briefly describe them and identify where they may be found.  Discuss how you might use them in researching your topic.  Where possible, post or bring to class examples of the kind of primary sources you will use.  Attach a list of these resources to your essay.  Post your essay (c. 750 -1,000 words) on both the class discussion board and your group discussion board no later than Monday.  Post substantive comments on the work of the other members of your group before class on Wednesday. 

In Class:

Come to class prepared to make a brief (5-6 minute), carefully organized oral presentation on what you have discovered.  For details,  see Tips for Making a Class Presentation.


Wednesday, October 31: No Class Meeting  Work on your Prospectus (due November 20) and Power Point Presentation (due November 26).

History, real solemn history, I cannot be interested in. . . . I read it a little as a duty; but it tells me nothing that does not either vex or weary me. The quarrels of popes and kings, with wars and pestilences in every page; the men all so good for nothing, and hardly any women at all. -- Jane Austen

Review A Template for Preparing your Prospectus.

NOTE:  October 31-November 14: Schedule an individual meeting with  Professor Griffith to review the status of your progress.  Please note that this meeting is mandatory.


Wednesday, November 7: No Class Meeting  Work on your Prospectus (due November 20) and Power Point Presentation (due November 26).

Time in its irresistible and ceaseless flow carries along on its flood all created things and drowns them in the depths of obscurity. . . . But the tale of history forms a very strong bulwark against the stream of time, and checks in some measure its irresistible flow, so that, of all things done in it, as many as history has taken over it secures and binds together, and does not allow them to slip away into the abyss of oblivion. -- Anna Comnena   (1083-1153), Byzantine Historian of the First Crusade

Review A Template for Preparing your Prospectus.

NOTE:  October 31-November 14: Schedule an individual meeting with  Professor Griffith to review the status of your progress.  Please note that this meeting is mandatory.



Wednesday, November 14:  No Class MeetingWork on Prospectus and Power Point Presentation

Review A Template for Preparing your Prospectus.

NOTE:  October 31-November 14: Schedule an individual meeting with  Professor Griffith to review the status of your progress.  Please note that this meeting is mandatory.


Wednesday, November 21:  Thanksgiving Break Begins.

For better or worse, I think one of the things I am supposed to do is challenge and even upset students. Not because unhappiness is good in and of itself. Far from it. But, increasingly, Americans are a people without history, with only memory, which means a people poorly prepared for what is inevitable about life -- tragedy, sadness, moral ambiguity -- and, therefore, a people reluctant to engage difficult ethical issues. Consumer culture is mostly about denial, about forgetting the past, except insofar as the past is pleasant and, thus, marketable. As historians, we occupy one tiny space where the richness of the past is kept alive, where its complexity is acknowledged and studied, where competing voices can still be heard. One of the most important things historians do is to bear witness to the past, including its horrors, in order to battle the amnesia that would sweep away all that is difficult or repugnant. The distinction between history and memory -- that is, the distinction between knowledge of painful things, painfully arrived at, and notions of the past that flatter us with easy myths or cheap emotions -- is at the heart of our enterprise.  --Elliott J. Gorn


 

Assignment Eight:

Post a completed first draft of your Prospectus on  both the class discussion board and your group discussion board  your  before you leave for Thanksgiving vacation,  no later than Tuesday, November 20.

Post substantive comments, suggestions and corrections on the prospectuses posted by the other members of your group no later than Wednesday, December 5.  You may want to download your classmates prospectus and, using Word's editing and comment function, make your suggestions electronically.  Then, upload the paper with your corrections using Blackboard's reply function.  Please note: your contribution to the work of others is an important (and graded!) part of the course.


Wednesday, November 28:  Presentations of Your Prospectuses (1) 

People are trapped in History, and History is trapped in them! --James Baldwin

 

Assignment Nine (1):   On Wednesday, November 28, half of the members of the class will make oral, Power Point presentations based on their prospectuses.  The presentations should be no longer than ten minutes, with time for Q&A afterwards.  Attendance is mandatory.

Your power point presentation must be uploaded to your "G" drive and a link to it posted on the  both the class discussion board and your group discussion board no later than Sunday, November 26. 

Reminder: Post substantive comments, suggestions and corrections on the prospectuses posted by the other members of your group no later than Wednesday, December 5.  You may want to download your classmates prospectus and, using Word's editing and comment function, make your suggestions electronically.  Then, upload the paper with your corrections using Blackboard's reply function.  Please note: your contribution to the work of others is an important (and graded!) part of the course.

 



Wednesday, December 5. Presentations of Your Prospectuses (2) 

Faithfulness to the truth of history involves far more than a research, however patient and scrupulous, into special facts. Such facts may be detailed with the most minute exactness, and yet the narrative, taken as a whole, may be unmeaning or untrue. The narrator must seek to imbue himself with the life and spirit of the time. He must study events in their bearings near and remote; in the character, habits, and manners of those who took part in them. He must himself be, as it were, a sharer or a spectator of the action he describes. -- Francis Parkman

 

Assignment Nine (2):   On Wednesday, December 5, the remaining members of the class will make oral, Power Point presentations based on their prospectuses.  The presentations should be no longer than ten minutes, with time for Q&A afterwards.  Attendance mandatory.

Your power point presentation must be uploaded to your "G" drive and a link to it posted on your  both the class discussion board and your group discussion board no later than Sunday, December  3rd 

Reminder: Post substantive comments, suggestions and corrections on the prospectuses posted by the other members of your group no later than Wednesday, December 5.  You may want to download your classmates prospectus and, using Word's editing and comment function, make your suggestions electronically.  Then, upload the paper with your corrections using Blackboard's reply function.  Please note: your contribution to the work of others is an important (and graded!) part of the course.


Friday, December 14: Final (revised) Draft of your Prospectus Due
 

It is among history’s virtues that it is, at last, impossible.  No tale, of course, can capture much of the past, so every narrative, blatant in its incompleteness, just come upon the mind as an artifice, a willed confection, always questionable, with luck entertaining, and entertainment is not the least of history’s purposes.  Not only is every tale partial and artful, but there is no obvious order in the past, no single construct that can satisfactorily encompass the change and sameness that any account requires for accuracy.  Disorderly, fragmentary, malleable, history leaves room for diverse participation.  The professionals cannot do it perfectly, so all can take a turn.  They must.  Everyone is obliged by history’s cultural importance and its clear use in planning, to try at times to pull a little account of the past into order, to act like a historian.

 

The Assignment Ten:  Post this final class assignment on the Class Discussion Board no later than Friday, December 14th.


Page last revised August, 2007
Comments: bgriff@american.edu